If that be so, then it is merely a matter of the modern form ofĮxpressing the subjunctive through the use of auxiliaries having become So then, it seems to me, must be the former. Subjunctive, duly cast in the past tense to show unlikelihood (or, here, Materially from "I wish I *had* wings." The latter is assuredly a proper Infelicitously on most native speakers' ears, but it seems not to differ It sounds very strange, and would fall most Strive as I may-and perhaps I am overlooking something obvious thatĪnother can supply-I see no reason why "I wish it *stopped* raining" īut for the possessor of a magic ring or the like: Since it is not a wish likely to be realized. "I wish it *went* as well with everybody as with me," Of a wish-express or implied-seems probable, the past when it does not: Normally, the present tense is used in the subjunctive when fulfillment 'I wish it went as well with everybody as with me.' Optative subjunctive, just as a conditionality ("If.") mandates the potential subjunctive. It would not be a replacement for the subjunctive but an alternative form of it.Īny statement expressing a wish mandates the Curme's (which I'm using myself).ĭoes this mean that the backshift in 2 doesn't work as a replacement of the subjunctive mood form "would stop" in 1? BTW, his view of the "subjunctive mood" is based, I think, on G. And Eric's very well read in matters grammar. But great as it shows the current state of mind of the native user. I wish it stopped raining just on weekends, so we could have more picnics.Įric Walker has at the same external link this partly enlightening, partly befuddling answer. If your example referred to a general case, it would be alright: Refer to a present condition that was established sometime in the past.Įven the last example is expressing a wish about a generality it assumes that thisĮvent will be too short, like others of its type. "I wish it went on longer," Kelly said, watching someone fly high above the top of the T, legs hanging loose. įirst, it should be said (I wish it went without saying) that no racial implication was intended, by TIME or by the artist. I am well, thank God ! and health is dearer to. 'The world goes very well with me, master,' replied he ' I wish it went as well with everybody as with me. The example (2) you gave doesn't work because, as written, it refers John Flaherty has a beautiful explanation there, showing why only 1 is correct.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |